A cookie jar vanishes from the kitchen shelf. Three kids each make a statement, and exactly one of the three is lying.
- Ana: "Ben took the cookies."
- Ben: "Cy is telling the truth."
- Cy: "I did not take the cookies."
- Exactly one of the three is lying.
Who took the cookies?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Ana
Test each suspect as the thief. If Ben took them, Ana's claim is true and Cy's denial is true, so Ben's claim about Cy is also true. Nobody lies, which breaks the rule. If Cy took them, Cy's denial is false, Ben's claim about Cy is false, and Ana's claim is false too: three liars. If Ana took them, Ana's claim is false (she is the liar), Cy's denial is true and Ben's claim is true. Exactly one liar, so Ana took the cookies.