A window is broken during break time, and four pupils each say something. Exactly two of them are lying.
- Ava: "I did not break the window."
- Bo: "Cem broke the window."
- Cem: "Ava is lying."
- Dina: "Bo or Cem broke the window."
- Exactly two of the four are lying.
Who broke the window?
Think it through first. When you're ready:
Bo
If Bo broke it, Ava is telling the truth, Bo's claim (Cem did it) is false, Cem's claim that Ava is lying is false, and Dina's claim is true. That is exactly two liars: Bo and Cem. If Ava broke it, Ava's claim is false, Cem's claim is true, Bo's claim is false and Dina's claim is false: three liars. If Cem broke it, Bo and Dina tell the truth but Cem's claim is false and Ava's claim is true: only one liar. If Dina broke it, Dina's claim is false and so are Bo's and Cem's: three liars. Only Bo fits.