🔴 Riddle #124 of 240
Two whole numbers are chosen, both greater than 1, different from each other, with a sum no greater than 100. Sam is told only their sum; Polly is told only their product. Both are perfect logicians. Polly says: "I don't know the numbers." Sam says: "I knew you didn't know." Polly says: "Now I know them." Sam says: "Now I know them too." What are the two numbers?
Think about it first. When you're ready:
4 and 13
Applying the four statements in turn to every pair with sum at most 100 leaves only (4, 13), which an exhaustive check confirms.